Like most companies, our beginnings were humble. In 1901, we started with $100,000 of capital,
3 employees, and a small number of Illinois merchants, farmers, and homeowners who purchased
our fire insurance policy. Our name was Illinois Mutual Fire Insurance Company.
By the 1960s, under the leadership of Marvin E. Pritikin, we merged with Founders Mutual
Insurance Company, which mainly wrote fire coverage for foundry workers, and converted to a stock
company under the name of Illinois Founders Insurance Company. We were among the first insurers
to issue payments to Chicago policyholders who lost their homes as a result of the civil unrest
following the assassination of Martin Luther King in 1968. In one case, we issued payment with only a picture of the
house once standing and a burnt mailbox with the house numbers on it! We began writing liquor liability
coverage, a current speciality of ours, for Illinois taverns and restaurants at the end of the 1950s.
Mr. Pritikin, in his 60s and without family in the business, sold Illinois Founders to the Lutz family
in 1982. In 1990, Illinois Founders added personal automobile to our lines of business. We dropped
"Illinois" from our name in 1999 to reflect our expansion into additional states.
Following the death of Michael Lutz, the family patriarch, in 2009, the Lutz family sold Founders to Utica Mutual Insurance
Company on June 30, 2010.
As a member of the Utica National Insurance Group, our surplus exceeds $69 million, our writings exceed $88 million,
we employ about 180 people spread over five states, and we are rated A- (Excellent) by A.M. Best. Headquartered just north of
Chicago's O'Hare airport, we are still writing the same coverages for homeowners, automobile owners,
and business owners, but our writings now span 22 states. Some of the things
that make us special to our agent-partners are:
- Financial strength
- Willingness to expand into new markets and develop new niche products
- Technology integration
- Superior underwriting, billing, and claims service
- An energetic, diverse workforce speaking nearly 18 different languages
- Emphasis on polite and friendly personal relationships
- Dedication to the independent agent
- Most importantly, integrity
Contact us today about an appointment.